Thanks for visiting this blog, created in July 2012 out of great concern for the fate of the €uro currency area, once again on the verge of collapse due to the economically ill-advised and heartless austerity policies imposed on Greece, Spain and other heavily-indebted €uro area countries by a christian democratic German chancellor impressed with the budgeting skills of Schwabian housewives. Meant to reduce the public debt and put the countries back on a path to economic growth, these macro-economically idiotic policies are doing anything but cause "pointless misery" as Paul Krugman so aptly describes it (Bloomberg, July 23-29, 2012).

Instead of reducing public debt, the austerity measures set in motion a vicious cycle of economic contraction, rising unemployment and poverty, lower tax revenues, private capital flight, and rising public debt shares as the economy declines faster than the public debt. What’s more, the austerity-driven ‘blood, sweat and tears’ policies recommended to the European periphery derive from the same economic doctrine that brought us to the brink of disaster in 2008. These policies are not only misanthropic and counterproductive to economic growth and debt reduction in Europe, but will prove explosive for the €uro currency area unless a drastic change of course takes place - and soon.

While I do not pretend to have ‘the’ solution for the €uro crisis, I would like to offer alternative economic perspectives and views on current events, and hope to chart a more humane path toward a balanced, socially fair, and sustainable economic future for the €uro area.

On the origins of the 2008 Great Financial Crisis:
“
90+% of traders are men, and they bet all of our bank deposits on liar loans which froze credit leading to 40% average losses passed on to ordinary taxpayers; then begged for trillion-dollar bailouts upon which they paid themselves 50% higher boni.”


Sunday, May 4, 2014

Back in the market-conform Euro zone

Dear readers,

I am finally back in Europe after a long trip to prepare a trans-atlantic move. No, I'm not giving up on Europe, just seizing better opportunities elsewhere for lady economists.

Back in the euro zone, the atmosphere is definitely scary:

Three weeks before the European election on May 25, there is a deafening silence in Germany - much like the somniferous national election campaign of last year. The economic and humanitarian crisis affecting European citizens in Southern Europe and the very real threat of a deflationary spiral in the euro zone is either not discussed or smoothed over by the mainstream press, indoctrinating German voters with news about alleged economic recoveries, primary surpluses, improving growth rates, and broadly orchestrated PR on crisis countries' return to financial markets.  

A perfect example of such orchestrated PR was Greece's successful return to international bond markets, widely viewed as necessary to prevent an electoral victory sweep by the European left: First, the terrain was prepared with news of Greece's primary surplus, forecasted economic growth, and improved competitiveness (i.e. drastically lower labor costs). Second, Greek bankers went on international road shows in the US and UK for Greek bond placements. Well aware that Greece's failure to return to financial markets could mean a victory of the left as well as the immediate stop of market-friendly structural reforms in the euro zone, the markets played along: Greek bond issues were greeted with unprecedented investor interest and heavy oversubscriptions. And so it was for the first Greek sovereign bond issue since early 2010: notwithstanding macroeconomic fundamentals such as 27% unemployment (over 50% for the young), a 25% shrinkage in Greece's GDP vs. 2009 and a 175.7% debt-to-GDP-ratio (compared with 129.7% in 2009), the 5-yr, €3 billion bond issue by the Hellenic Republic was 8 (eight !) times oversubscribed. 

Third, Germany's chancellor Merkel made the final PR point so that everyone would understand. Days after Greece's successful return to international bond markets Merkel visited Greek prime minister Samaras to pat him on the back for his successful austerity and reform strategy. By then, the message was loud and clear to everyone: "Our strategy is working. If you, dear European voter, want Europe's recovery and success on financial markets to continue you need to vote for us, not the left."

And yet, this perfectly orchestrated PR-campaign didn't quite 'catch', at least not in the more critical blogger scene far away from Frankfurt am Mainstream. This financial blogger's comment, including a telling Goldman Sachs press notice, says it all:  "Greek bond final term sheet..." See also MacroPolis "...The perils of ignoring macro-economic fundamentals".

If Europe's VSPs think European voters are idiots who happily continue to suffer and then turn the other cheek, they should not be offended if Europe's extreme right has a landslide victory on May 25, then dissolves the European parliament and starts the Third World War in Ukraine.

Yes, I think the situation is that serious. And no, I will not stay and watch.

Monday, March 17, 2014

Lady economist traveling

Dear loyal readers around the world,

I am currently on a long business trip, so posting will be sporadic.
Hope, I will be forgiven. Will be back soon.

Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Euro zone recovery ? If at all, highly imbalanced and with a lot of room for improvement



Europeans queuing for work.
Source:  Frankfurter Rundschau, March 2, 2014.

It is understandable that interested parties[1] aim to convince European voters that the euro zone is recovering from the crisis and that the structural reforms imposed on the periphery are showing results, namely lower risk spreads on euro zone government bonds, lower budget and trade account deficits, and blossoming economic growth.

While the lowering of budget and trade account deficits is mainly due to the severe economic austerity measures in the euro zone periphery, and +0.5% growth in the euro zone as a whole can hardly be called a success, it is true that risk spreads and yields on euro zone government bonds have normalized --> see this Bloomberg article of February 28, 2014, including yield chart for Greece: "Greek yields fall below 7% as crisis source regains confidence". There is no doubt, euro zone financial markets have calmed after ECB president Mario Draghi's historic proclamation "within our mandate, the ECB is ready to do whatever it takes to preserve the euro" of July 2012. Recent euro zone bond sales have shown that there seems to be no stopping the appetite of yield-hungry investors as long as ECB accommodation remains favorable. 

The other side of the euro story, however, conveniently remains unmentioned. Fortunately, there are still critical economists who look under the superficial veneer of the euro zone. See, for example, Yanis Varoufakis' recent economic update on Greece: "What you should know about Greece's present state of affairs." Or the Frankfurter Rundschau's thorough review of economic and social developments in Italy, Greece, Portugal and Spain: "Union der Armen." Or my own assessment of the economic impact of hundreds of €billions of taxpayer funds spent on bail-out and 'rescue' measures in the euro zone:

- Sovereign defaults have been avoided and zombie banks full of worthless assets have been saved.
- The economies of the euro zone periphery contracted severely, in Greece by 25% vs. 2009.
- Unemployment reached record levels in the periphery, among the under-25s over 50%.
- Public debt ratios are higher than 2009 as a consequence of the economic collapse in the periphery.
- Wages, pensions, and social security payments have been significantly cut, in Greece by 40%.  
- Poverty, misery, and hunger in the middle of wealthy Europe !

Conclusion: the euro and zombie banks have been saved, but the patient (the real economy and its people) is nearly dead. The pro-cyclical austerity policies combined with the wage-depressing structural competitiveness reforms have caused tremendous damage to the real economy and the social fabric of the euro zone periphery, and the damage is spreading to the core. Europe risks a lost decade with weak economic activity, high unemployment and rising poverty with dangerous deflationary tendencies, increasing the real value of public debt.  

Bravo, Merkel & Co. Great job !
No, in my monopoly game, you will NOT be able to get out of jail, collect €4000, and continue on.
I hope, European voters agree with me and show you so at the ballot box in May.
______________________
[1] namely those economic policy makers responsible for the euro zone 'rescue' measures and who are trying to win MEP seats in the European elections in May 2014. 

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Germany's Progressives are fighting while Latin Europe suffers and Big Business triumphs

For those who had hoped that Europe's progressives will, for once, work together to defeat conservative and ultra-right parties during the 2014 European election campaign so as to end the misery in the Southern European periphery, the recent attacks by leading members of Germany's green party against Sahra Wagenknecht (co-chair of Germany's LINKE) is a huge disappointment.

But first the background to all the fuss:

On February 13, Zeit Online published an interview with Sahra Wagenknecht in which she states the obvious, namely that the Euro system - as it is now - does not function very well but divides Europe. Following that, a number of suggestive questions by Zeit Online meant to make the reader think that Ms. Wagenknecht agrees with her partner Oscar Lafontaine who favors a replacement of the euro with a new European currency system. 

The Greens responded by Blitz-attack: on the same day, Simone Peters, co-chair of the Green party, accused Wagenknecht of nationalism and populism on the same level as the AfD (Alternative für Deutschland), the new ultra-right party in Germany.  Two days later, Sven Giegold, MEP co-leader of the German greens' European election campaign, challenged Ms. Wagenknecht to support progressive economic policies, insinuating that she was instead following down the path of the "nationalist grave diggers of the euro" (his words). Here is a very good rebuttal to Giegold's non-sense: "Sven Giegold und die grüne Verdrängungsmaschine".
   
The attacks from the Greens came on the heel of a scandalously rude and disrespectful interview of Ms. Wagenknecht by a talk-show moderator on German public TV who attempted to convince the audience that Wagenknecht was out to destroy the euro. Even the mainstream Spiegel Online thought that was too much, opining that this interview was "the expression of an aggressive conformism that pervades the entire ZDF". (ZDF, the second German public TV station is financed by tax payers but heavily influenced by Big Business with key supporters on Germany's public media board).

Considering the above-mentioned events, an interest-led PR campaign against the LINKE doesn't seem far-fetched. Question is: are the Greens, as the direct competitior of the LINKE, being instrumentalized by Big Business or are they preparing for a future coalition with Merkel's pro-Big Business CDU ? Or are they just desperate in view of the negative press coverage they had recently ? ---> see "Europa-Parteitag: Pragmatisch, grün, langweilig",  "Grosses Gerangel um Spitzenpositionen", heute-show: Lutz van der Horst im Einsatz gegen das Charisma-Defizit der Grünen:


Whatever may be the reason for the greens' aggressive behavior against the LINKE, striking is the complete lack of humor among the German greens displayed in the video, with the sole exception of Claudia Roth. But what's really deadly is the desperate but futile attempt of Germany's leading greens to appear cool - sad ! 

Meanwhile, Big Business and Big Finance are living it up, enjoying the fruits of their successful 'divide and rule' strategy among Europe's (and America's) progressives: see "Troika consultancies: a multi-billion business beyond scrutiny" and "I crashed a Wall Street Secret Society".

Tuesday, February 18, 2014

Is the Intellectual Edifice of the Competitiveness Doctrine crumbling as well ?

Following the crumbling of "the intellectual edifice of austerity economics" (see also "Austerity....in Europe - economic incompetence or indoctrination ?") and the waning political support of austerity measures in the euro zone (see "Public Opinion in Germany turning broadly against Austerity"), the intellectual edifice of the Anglo-Germanic competitiveness doctrine (see also here) seems to be wasting away as well.

A recent World Bank contradicts the competitiveness doctrine with evidence that "changes in competitiveness, measured by real exchange rates or by unit labour costs, have not been strongly associated with external imbalances in the Eurozone periphery" (see the table below from the World Bank study "Tracking the causes of Eurozone external imbalances: new evidence", Sanchez and Varoudakis, February 2014). Instead, Sanchez and Varoudakis' analysis corroborates that:

"....the growing external imbalances in the Eurozone periphery were mainly driven by a domestic demand boom triggered by greater financial integration and the resulting surge in credit and intra-regional capital flows.".... "Growth and real interest rates have played a more important role in current-account dynamics in the Eurozone periphery than in the core."

Percentage of variation in current account explained by column variable
 (panel VAR estimated over 1996–2011)
Source: World Bank study, Sanchez and Varoudakis, February 2014, Table 1.

Savings–investment imbalances and competitiveness gaps 
in the Eurozone core and periphery (1990–2011)
Source: World Bank study, Sanchez and Varoudakis, February 2014, Figure 2.

Translating from economeze to understandable english: Sanchez and Varoudakis found that the introduction of the euro and the consequential disappearance of exchange rate risk in the euro zone led to a surge of capital flows from the capital-rich core to the periphery. This capital surge in turn led to increases in economic growth, unit labor costs, and prices; thus, to an increase in inflation rates, a decline in real interest rates, and an appreciation of the real exchange rates of the euro zone periphery countries vs. the core. As a logical economic consequence of these developments, the current account balances of the euro zone periphery countries registered growing deficits while current accounts in the euro zone core showed rising surpluses, thus generating growing imbalances in the euro zone as a whole.

Given these developments, the often proclaimed loss of competitiveness due to higher unit labor costs is an endogenous explanatory factor for the problems in the euro zone periphery, i.e. a factor derived from other, more significant, economic developments as described above. Hence, the policy recommendations to correct the problems in the euro zone periphery should be directed at the economic factor(s) that caused the problems, in this case mainly the capital surge from the euro zone core.

Sanchez and Varoudakis hold similar views, albeit framed in rather 'diplomatic' language. They conclude that "Tighter regulation of credit markets, including through macroprudential measures, might .... be needed to thwart excess leverage and concentration of lending in investments prone to speculative bubbles."

With respect to the ill-advised, deflationary competitiveness measures favored by Merkel & Co. (i.e. cuts in wage and non-wage labor costs to reduce unit labor costs = internal devaluation), they suggest that "Internal devaluation may have certainly contributed to a contraction of domestic demand....an unintended consequence of this correction has been a potentially large redistribution of income at the expense of wage earners in the periphery." 

Finally, Sanchez and Varoudakis recommend a very different reform agenda to remedy external balances, prevent future crises, and attain medium-term economic growth:

"Structural reforms that improve the business environment and investments that enhance productivity hold the key to external rebalancing and stronger medium-term growth (Gill and Raiser 2012). This broader structural reform agenda, as well as complementary, productivity-enhancing public investments in physical and human capital, should not be lost from sight ...."

Quite in line with my own policy recommendations, with the exception of the well-worn phrase "structural reforms that improve the business environment" (code for wage-depressing, deflationary labor market liberalization).

Thursday, February 6, 2014

Economic Policy Recommendations to prevent a Lost Decade in the Euro Zone


As a follow-up to my summary of the first Troika impact report, here are my economic policy recommendations to prevent a lost decade of deflation, depression, rising unemployment and poverty in the euro zone:

First: implement an immediate STOP of the deflationary austerity and competitiveness policies, at least until all the results of the Troika investigations have been reviewed and analyzed. After that, a democratic decision should be taken on how to proceed.

Second: for the short- to medium term, I recommend a macroeconomic strategy change toward active, job-creating economic policies with, for example, sound investments in renewable energy projects to reduce the costs of oil imports into the euro zone, and the massive employment of the most valuable renewable energy of the continent, namely our people, in the social service sector to benefit fellow Europeans, native animals, and the protection of the environment.

The financing of such welfare-enhancing investments and services should be derived NOT from new debt, but from the revenues of an adequately designed financial transactions tax as well as bank fees for the speedy reimbursement of tax payer-financed European bank bail-outs amounting to hundreds of billions of Euros (see the estimates by Sven Giegold at the bottom of his article). According to IMF data, only 15%-40% of these funds have so far been returned to Europe's taxpayers. The money is desperately needed NOW, not later, to repair the damage caused by the misguided austerity and competitiveness policies in the euro zone. If banks have the money to pay million-Euro bank salaries and boni again, they also have the funds to reimburse Europe's taxpayers !

Currently, we are saving at the wrong end and are rescuing the wrong ones, namely zombie banks that would not be able to survive without taxpayer support. That is why I also recommend:

Third, structural adjustment programs for Europe's banks, with strict conditionality for the orderly closure of zombie banks, and a restructuring of the remaining banks along the lines of the 14-point reform and adjustment program noted in my post of August 29, 2012 and the forthcoming study by Sven Giegold of the European Greens: “Banking structural reform; a Green perspective”. The conditionality of the structural adjustment programs should be regularly supervized and inspected by competent and democratically legitimized inspectors. 

Thursday, January 30, 2014

First impact report on the Troika's operations

Last October, I reported on Sven Giegold's initiative for an investigation of the Troika's operations by the European Parliament's powerful Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee (see my post of October 31, 2013: "Halloween in Europe...."). 

Well, the committee members didn't loose any time: they immediately sent out questionnaires to various stakeholders, including representatives of labor unions and high government officials of countries that signed reform programs designed and supervized by the Troika (EU commission, ECB and IMF). Throughout the month of January, EP delegations visited Portugal, Cyprus, Ireland, and Greece; meetings took place between national and EP delegates; and parliamentary hearings were held with key Troika officials, including economics commissioner Olli Rehn, former ECB-chief Trichet, and ESM-chief Regling (see "Auswertung der Troika-Arbeit: Anhörungen und Delegations-Besuche).



On January 28, the first impact report of the Troika's operations was presented, based on a thorough analysis of replies to questionnaires sent to affiliates of the European Trade Union Confederation (ETUC) in Cyprus, Greece, Ireland, and Portugal. The findings are devastating:

The Troika's policies of fiscal consolidation are overly ambitious and poorly designed, with little emphasis on the revenue side. The fiscal consolidation measures, combined with a dismantling of systems of social protection, and the complete lack of counterbalancing measures to promote growth and employment have severely damaged domestic demand and triggered a deep recession. 

The Troika's structural competitiveness reforms promote labor market deregulation, dismantle wage bargaining systems, abolish key workers' rights and enforce cuts in minimum wages, public sector salaries and pensions, often under the threat of ceasing loan instalments (e.g. in Greece).

Economic impact: The deep recession caused by the Troika's fiscal austerity measures has shrunk the economy, worsened public finances and increased public debt levels. It has also led to a fall in or a complete collapse of investment activity, despite severe wage cuts. Troika demands for privatizations of public assets at fire sale prices are bound to lead to private oligopolies.

Social impact: Skilled workers and qualified young people are leaving the crisis countries while the remaining population suffers record unemployment and soaring poverty, rendering a significant part of the population destitute. "There is a tremendous rise in indebted households, with the unemployed and homeless being forced to turn to soup kitchens and food distribution." (e.g. Greece) Inequality is widening, with rising unemployment and the dismantling of social protection measures the main drivers. 

Political impact: The imposition of reform policies by unelected Troika officials are putting democracy under heavy strain. Citizens feel they are being overtaken by rules that are external to them and not in their or their country's best interest but "instead serve to uphold the 'sanctity of debt' at all cost" to spare the banking systems of creditor nations. Only 15% of Southern European citizens trust their countries' government, between 19% (Greece) and 43% (Italy) approve of the EU leadership, and less than 30% maintain their faith in democracy.

Legal impact: The report makes it clear that key provisions of the European Treaty, such as "the obligation of the European Union to recognise and promote social dialogue and the autonomy of social partners (Article 152 TFEU)", have not been respected at all. Instead, the European Commissiion has actively assisted in a breach of these provisions, going "against major principles of the European Social Acquis". The report concludes: "Fundamental principles and key objectives of the European Treaty are there to be respected at all times. .... the failure of the Troika programmes to deliver economic and social results shows that the respect of Treaty provisions is a necessary guarantee to design policies that actually work."

No need to say anymore. This report speeks eloquently for itself !